I found plaquemaker.com via a Web search and thought they could give me what I needed. They offer aluminum and stainless steel tags and plaques in custom sizes. I did some math and decided on 2.25" by .5". I included a picture of Goose's MFP tag and had to have the proof modified a couple of times before they got the font sizing right. Shipping took too long. They use UPS Mail Innovations which means UPS picks it up and then it goes to USPS for delivery, and that's just stupid. Also, they notified me that the order had shipped but it didn't actually leave the building for several days.
My badges arrived this past Saturday. The font and size are OK, but they were obviously printed on a larger aluminum sheet and then cut out with tin snips. The edges have burrs, which is understandable, but the cuts aren't straight and the badges aren't even square (I guess that's what they mean by "custom cut"). I’m surprised they thought a customer would find that acceptable. I don’t have time before the RW event to go through a lengthy exchange process, so I filed them down myself and replaced the pinbacks with clutchback pins. As you might imagine, I don't recommend this vendor. About the only thing I'm happy with is that the printing is flat (it's dye sublimation, not engraving).
Here's a pic of the badges pre-mod:

Goose's badge for comparison:

I'll post newer pix soon.